Despite widespread acknowledgment of the judiciary's shortcomings among the populace, the election has faced backlash from opposition and legal scholars who claim it could allow Morena excessive control over the judicial branch. Critics fear the new system sacrifices career qualifications, resulting in candidates easily swayed by outside influences, including organized crime.

With such a daunting task and an overwhelming number of candidates—over 7,700—many anticipated a sluggish voter turnout. As voting commenced, reports indicated that queues at polling stations were notably sparse. Jazmín Gutiérrez Ruiz, a 37-year-old from Tultitlán, expressed hope that the elections would pave the way for accountability and justice, sharing her personal motivation stemming from her brothers' wrongful incarceration. She emphasized the mayor need for judges who would diligently evaluate cases to prevent injustices from continuing.

As voters stepped into democratic action, Mexico's judicial reform faced both hopeful participation and critical scrutiny, setting the stage for potential change in a historically complex governance structure.