Russian Mother and Daughters Found Living in Cave: An Unlikely Story of Survival in India

Nina Kutina, a Russian woman, and her two daughters were found living in a cave in southern India's Karnataka, sparking intrigue about their lifestyle, her immigration status, and the circumstances that led them to this unusual existence. Kutina asserts they were content in their cave dwelling, while authorities prepare for their deportation.

Police in India are investigating the curious case of a Russian woman, Nina Kutina, who was residing in a cave in Karnataka along with her two young daughters. Discovered on July 9 during a routine patrol near Ramteertha hills, the 40-year-old and her daughters, aged six and five, reportedly lack valid documentation to remain in India and have since been placed in a detention center for foreigners in Bengaluru, pending deportation.

In interviews with Indian news agency ANI, Kutina defended her existence in the cave, expressing happiness and a belief in the health benefits of nature. The lack of clarity surrounding their presence in the forest—a region marked by wildlife dangers—raises various questions, including how long they had lived there and the specifics of their journey.

The region, known for its beauty and popularity among tourists, has seen police patrols initiated last year due to concerns about safety. Upon stumbling upon their cave, officers described colourful saris draped across the entrance and a young girl approaching them, prompting a closer inspection that revealed the family’s meager possessions, including instant noodles and makeshift bedding.

While officers were surprised at their comfort level in the cave, they voiced concerns over potential risks, particularly from snakes and wild animals. In response, Kutina emphasized her preference for nature over urban living, stating, "Animals and snakes are our friends. Humans are dangerous."

Authorities confirmed that Kutina is of Russian nationality and plans to repatriate her once necessary proceedings are completed. Reports indicate Kutina has not lived in Russia for over 15 years and has traveled extensively, claiming her eldest son passed away in a vehicular accident in Goa last year while another son remains in Russia.

The case has drawn the attention of Kutina’s children’s father, Dror Goldstein, an Israeli businessman, who wishes to secure joint custody of his daughters, stating he filed a missing persons report after Kutina left Goa unannounced. He is currently discussing arrangements for their return.

While the exact timeline of Kutina and her children’s stay in the cave is unclear, police cited her claims that they had lived there for a week and purchased supplies from a nearby store shortly before their discovery. Her expired passport indicated that her initial visa had long since lapsed, raising further questions about her immigration status.

Kutina has criticized her detention, likening it to imprisonment and expressing concern over the unsatisfactory conditions compared to their previous living situation. In her interviews, she directly mentioned the beneficial aspects of living in proximity to nature, arguing against the assumption that her choices posed risks to her daughters' well-being.

Furthermore, while officers found religious artifacts indicating possible spiritual motivations for her dwelling choice, Kutina dismissed such narratives, insisting her preference is simply a love for the natural environment. She described the beauty of the cave and the joy her daughters experienced there, highlighting their engagement in creative activities and nourishment through home-cooked meals.

As investigations continue, the need for understanding the complexities of this family's situation remains urgent, shedding light on broader themes of immigration, lifestyle choices, and the pursuit of happiness amidst societal norms.