In brief
Tina Peters, previously the Mesa County elections clerk, is petitioning the Colorado appeals court to acknowledge President Trump's pardon for her state crimes as valid. Peters' legal team asserts the court’s jurisdiction is nullified by the pardon. Despite Trump's authority traditionally being limited to federal convictions, Peters' case references historical examples of state and federal pardons. The court is to hear her case on January 14, while state responses to her claims are due by January 8.
DENVER (RTW News) — Tina Peters, the former Colorado elections clerk, is making a notable move in her ongoing legal battle by asking the state appeals court to recognize President Donald Trump’s pardon of her state convictions as valid.
In a motion submitted on Tuesday, Peters’ legal team argued that the appeals court's jurisdiction over her conviction is nullified because of a pardon issued by Trump on December 5. Additionally, they are seeking her immediate release from prison, claiming the pardon should be adhered to.
Peters was convicted in connection with a data breach scheme driven by unfounded claims of voting machine fraud during the 2020 presidential election. Notably, Trump does not have the authority to pardon state crimes, a key argument anticipated to be addressed in the upcoming court hearing.
In the recent filing, Peters’ lawyers pointed out historical precedents from the late 18th century, suggesting that prior presidents have pardoned individuals convicted of both state and federal offenses. They have requested the court move swiftly in its deliberation. The appeals court has scheduled to hear arguments from Peters' attorneys on January 14.
[Ad Placement]On Wednesday, the appeals court directed the attorneys from the state attorney general's office, defending the conviction, to respond to Peters’ arguments by January 8.
Attorney General Phil Weiser's office has previously stated that attempting to apply a presidential pardon to a state conviction lacks precedent and is fundamentally flawed.
“The notion that a president could pardon someone convicted in state court is an unprecedented action and will not be supported by our constitution,” Weiser noted in a prior statement regarding Trump’s announcement of the pardon.
If the appeals court ultimately rules that Trump's pardon is not valid, one of Peters' attorneys indicated that the case could be escalated to the U.S. Supreme Court while the state court reviews Peters’ appeal of her conviction.
Peters was sentenced to nine years in prison, with the presiding judge highlighting her role in undermining public trust in the electoral process.
Throughout her trial and sentencing, Peters maintained her belief that her actions were foundational in addressing supposed election fraud.
In her conviction, she triumphed an individual associated with MyPillow's Mike Lindell to access secure election systems, which solidified the case against her amidst her promotion of false narratives surrounding Trump's election loss.




