In brief
The Montana Supreme Court has dismissed a misconduct case against Attorney General Austin Knudsen, who faced scrutiny for violating professional conduct rules during a dispute involving a law granting the governor judicial appointment powers. While the court found his conduct inappropriate, it ruled in favor of Knudsen on procedural grounds, emphasizing the need for due process in legal proceedings.
BILLINGS, Mont. (AP) — Montana’s Supreme Court on Wednesday dismissed a misconduct case against the state’s attorney general after he defied court orders in a dispute over a law that gave the governor more power over the judiciary.
A court-appointed panel last year found that Republican Attorney General Austin Knudsen repeatedly attacked the integrity of the justices in his defense of a 2021 law permitting the state’s Republican governor to directly fill judicial vacancies.
The panel had recommended that Knudsen’s license to practice law be suspended for 90 days.
Justices agreed in Wednesday’s ruling that Knudsen had violated rules of professional conduct for attorneys. But the court said the panel that handled the case violated Knudsen’s due process rights by excluding his expert witness and failing to adequately explain its decision against him.
Knudsen had urged the high court to dismiss the case, stating that the complaint against him was a distraction. I appreciate the Supreme Court bringing this frivolous complaint to a long-overdue conclusion,” Knudsen stated. We’ve said it from the very beginning, this was nothing more than a political stunt.”
Chief Justice Cory Swanson described Wednesday’s order as a “public admonition” over Knudsen’s misconduct. He emphasized the necessity for all Montana attorneys, including Knudsen, to adhere to lawful court orders.
The controversy centered around a law pushed by the Republican legislature, which was part of a nationwide GOP effort to reinforce a more conservative judiciary. The law was later upheld by the Montana Supreme Court.
During the legal proceedings, Knudsen’s office accused the justices of judicial misconduct and self-dealing, which only added intensity to the disputes with the judicial branch.
In dismissing the case, the court reinforced the principles of due process in legal proceedings, an essential factor for maintaining public confidence in the justice system. While all but two justices recused themselves from the case, it was noted that the ruling highlighted fundamental issues surrounding accountability and the ethical standards expected from the state's top law enforcement officer.


