Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier has expressed zero tolerance for any form of animal abuse, echoing sentiments from animal rights organizations. Following a request by Uthmeier, an extensive search warrant was executed by Florida's Department of Law Enforcement along with the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC). Reports suggest that park officials obstructed the FWC rangers from assessing the welfare of the animals.

The Dolphin Company, the parent owners of the marine park, have yet to respond to inquiries regarding these allegations. Among the injured animals, a fourth dolphin is believed to have recently died after an accident in the pool during a performance. The park's website lists various species in its care, including bottlenose dolphins, sea lions, and various birds and reptiles.

Phil Demers, director of the animal advocacy group UrgentSeas, has drawn attention to the deteriorating conditions within the park, stating, “We are dedicated to documenting and highlighting the distressing circumstances faced by animals at Gulf World Marine Park.” He issued a chilling warning, asserting that the welfare of these animals may be compromised if prompt action to rescue them is not taken.

Animal rights groups and the local community are closely monitoring the situation, calling for transparency and accountability regarding the treatment of animals in captivity. As authorities continue their investigation, the future of Gulf World Marine Park remains uncertain.