In a significant legal development, the New Zealand High Court has overturned the earlier conviction of Whakaari Management Limited (WML), previously found guilty of failing to ensure visitor safety during the 2019 volcanic eruption. The court ruled that WML, which is solely the landowner, could not be held liable for the day-to-day safety of visitors. The 2019 eruption, which occurred while many tourists were on the island, led to widespread fatalities and injuries, prompting a large inquiry into safety regulations. The decision marks a pivotal moment for the Buttles, the family who has owned the island since the 1930s, offering clarity on the responsibilities of landowners allowing public access.
High Court Overturns Conviction of New Zealand Volcano Owners in Deadly Eruption
High Court Overturns Conviction of New Zealand Volcano Owners in Deadly Eruption
The High Court of New Zealand has vacated the 2023 conviction of the owners of Whakaari/White Island for the 2019 eruption that claimed 22 lives.
With the ruling, there remains significant discussion surrounding regulatory accountability and safety oversight in natural disaster contexts, as other parties, including tour operators, still face charges related to the tragedy.
The article text follows:
The owners of a New Zealand volcano that erupted in 2019, killing 22 people, have had their conviction over the disaster thrown out by the country's High Court. Whakaari Management Limited (WML) was found guilty in 2023 of failing to keep visitors safe and fined just over NZ$1m ($560,000; £445,000). They were also ordered to pay NZ$4.8m in reparation to the victims. However, following an appeal, the High Court ruled on Friday that the company only owned the land and were not responsible for people's safety.
White Island, which is also known by its Māori name, Whakaari, is New Zealand's most active volcano and has been erupting in some form since 2011. It had been showing signs of heightened unrest for weeks before the fatal December 2019 eruption, which killed almost half of the people who were on it at the time. Most were tourists, including 17 from Australia and three from the US. Another 25 people were injured, with many suffering extensive burns.
High Court Justice Simon Moore said on Friday that while WML licensed tours of the volcano, there was nothing in these agreements that gave the company control of what was happening on the island day to day. He agreed that it was reasonable for the company to rely on tour operators, as well as emergency management and science organisations, to assess risks to safety. Justice Moore added that, in coming to his decision, he had not ignored the pain and grief of the families that had been affected. "It is impossible not to be deeply moved and affected by the sheer scale and nature of the human loss in this case," he said.
Thirteen parties in total, including tour operators, were charged over the disaster. WML was the last to receive a verdict after six had pleaded guilty, while six more had their charges dismissed. The case against WML was the largest action of its kind brought by New Zealand's regulator, Worksafe NZ, who said it acknowledged the High Court ruling and was considering whether to appeal. James Cairney, a lawyer for James, Andrew and Peter Buttle - three brothers who own the company - said the family welcomed the decision, Radio New Zealand reported. He added that the Buttles hoped it would "bring certainty for all landowners who grant others recreational access to their land". The Buttle family has owned Whakaari/White Island since the 1930s, when their grandfather bought it and placed it in a family trust. It is one of only a few privately owned islands in New Zealand. The brothers had previously been on trial in relation to the 2019 disaster as individuals over alleged breaches of New Zealand's workplace health and safety legislation. Those charges were dismissed in 2023.
Millions awarded to White Island volcano victims. Company found guilty over NZ volcano disaster. New Zealand volcano. New Zealand.
The article text follows:
The owners of a New Zealand volcano that erupted in 2019, killing 22 people, have had their conviction over the disaster thrown out by the country's High Court. Whakaari Management Limited (WML) was found guilty in 2023 of failing to keep visitors safe and fined just over NZ$1m ($560,000; £445,000). They were also ordered to pay NZ$4.8m in reparation to the victims. However, following an appeal, the High Court ruled on Friday that the company only owned the land and were not responsible for people's safety.
White Island, which is also known by its Māori name, Whakaari, is New Zealand's most active volcano and has been erupting in some form since 2011. It had been showing signs of heightened unrest for weeks before the fatal December 2019 eruption, which killed almost half of the people who were on it at the time. Most were tourists, including 17 from Australia and three from the US. Another 25 people were injured, with many suffering extensive burns.
High Court Justice Simon Moore said on Friday that while WML licensed tours of the volcano, there was nothing in these agreements that gave the company control of what was happening on the island day to day. He agreed that it was reasonable for the company to rely on tour operators, as well as emergency management and science organisations, to assess risks to safety. Justice Moore added that, in coming to his decision, he had not ignored the pain and grief of the families that had been affected. "It is impossible not to be deeply moved and affected by the sheer scale and nature of the human loss in this case," he said.
Thirteen parties in total, including tour operators, were charged over the disaster. WML was the last to receive a verdict after six had pleaded guilty, while six more had their charges dismissed. The case against WML was the largest action of its kind brought by New Zealand's regulator, Worksafe NZ, who said it acknowledged the High Court ruling and was considering whether to appeal. James Cairney, a lawyer for James, Andrew and Peter Buttle - three brothers who own the company - said the family welcomed the decision, Radio New Zealand reported. He added that the Buttles hoped it would "bring certainty for all landowners who grant others recreational access to their land". The Buttle family has owned Whakaari/White Island since the 1930s, when their grandfather bought it and placed it in a family trust. It is one of only a few privately owned islands in New Zealand. The brothers had previously been on trial in relation to the 2019 disaster as individuals over alleged breaches of New Zealand's workplace health and safety legislation. Those charges were dismissed in 2023.
Millions awarded to White Island volcano victims. Company found guilty over NZ volcano disaster. New Zealand volcano. New Zealand.
