SNCF confirmed the fine was valid and in accordance with noise regulations despite the lack of a national law banning loudspeaker calls. Security personnel at SNCF are empowered to issue such fines to maintain peace at public transport facilities. Public opinion on using loudspeakers in shared environments remains overwhelmingly negative, prompting different approaches worldwide to enforce noise regulations. Countries like the UK and Japan have specific policies or cultural norms aimed at reducing disturbances from mobile phone usage, indicating a global dialogue over public conduct amidst evolving communication technology.
Fined for Speakerphone: Man Challenges €200 Penalty at Nantes Station
Fined for Speakerphone: Man Challenges €200 Penalty at Nantes Station
A man disputes a €200 fine for using loudspeaker on a call at a French train station.
A 54-year-old man has sparked controversy after receiving a €200 fine for making a loudspeaker call while at Nantes station, France. Identified only as David, he claims he was speaking with his sister when SNCF security staff intervened, initially threatening a €150 fine that allegedly escalated due to non-payment. David has sought legal representation, voicing disbelief at the incident, initially thinking it was a prank.
